Photographer's Note
I wanted to show three Kodachrome photos from the city of Porto, all partly featuring the famous Dom Luís I Bridge, built in the 1880's. But I had trouble scanning them, because they were not technically the best photos I had ever taken, and no matter how much I struggled with the PP I wasn't satisfied with the colours. So when it entered my mind that they all looked like scenes from Italian neorealistic films it became obvious that I had to make them in B&W.
Italian neorealism was a movement of filmmaking, roughly active from the end of WW2 through the 1950's. The crews stepped out of the studios into the streets and made stories concerning the poverty and social problems that plagued the nation after the years of war and decades of Fascism. In 1984, when I took these photos, Portugal was still struggling to overcome the legacy of dictatorship and costly colonial wars in Africa. The atmosphere I found in Portuguese cities reminded me a lot of the Rome, Milan or Naples that I had seen in the old B&W movies by directors like Roberto Rossellini, Luchino Visconti or Vittorio De Sica.
I have added workshop photos showing a man gone fishing in the Dourou river and laundry drying above the river. All photos were scanned from Kodachrome slides and converted to monochrome.
Here is a larger version of the main photo.
pajaran, Fis2, snunney, ChrisJ, ikeharel, PaulVDV, Royaldevon, alvaraalto, danos, Lidka, Cricri, cornejo, tyro, papagolf21, macjake, jhm, mcmtanyel, worldcitizen, PiotrF, COSTANTINO Ý÷ïõí(åé) åðéëÝîåé áõôÞ ôç óçìåßùóç ùò ÷ñÞóéìç
Critiques | Translate
pajaran
(102632) 2018-02-03 1:22
Dobar dan.
Interesantan i lep pogled, lep trenutak ...
Lepa crno bela fotografija, lepo pokazano mesto i trenutak.
Lepe fotografije u radionici.
Zelim vam lep dana, sve najbolje za vikend, srecno.
Paja.
Good day.
Interesting and beautiful view, a nice moment ...
Beautiful black and white photo, a nice place and moment.
Nice photo in the workshop.
I wish you a nice day, all the best for a weekend, happy.
Fis2
(155625) 2018-02-03 1:30
Witaj Gert!
Excellent b&w work.
A very interesting scene from daily life.
Good frame and composition.
I love it!
Bravo!
Have a good wekend.
Krzysztof
snunney
(130967) 2018-02-03 1:39
Hello Gert,
Black and white has its merits, particularly in difficult lighting conditions and for heightening the mood. I like the point of view here looking toward the bridge and the lively atmosphere. The image has a good range of tones and fine clarity.
Nicou
(193806) 2018-02-03 2:01
Hello
quelle image originale avec beaucoup d'éléments à découvrir ce pont en fond avec les voitures cette alignée de personnes sur le quai avec les pêcheur en homme en maillot de bain deux autre habillés dans l'eau quelle image génial superbe.
Bravo et amitié
Nicou
tenretin
(3145) 2018-02-03 2:02
Hello,
Ma première visite dans ce pays date de 2003. Déjà Porto ne présentait plus cet aspect. Cette photo est particulièrement intéressante et proche du documentaire. Merci pour la partage.
Cordialement,
JP
ikeharel
(105901) 2018-02-03 2:05
Hello Gert,
Seems as just yesterday taken this sight, the place looked the same when we were there on 10/2010, and I can only guess how colorful the scene was.
B&W off-set the faults mentioned, the outcome is a fine scan.
Wish you a nice weekend,
Ike
ChrisJ
(160008) 2018-02-03 2:06
Hello Gert,
All 3 images are fine and compliment each other. The guy in the main photo with a pot belly seems to be watching the fully clothed man retrieving a fish. I would not advise swimming so close to so many fishing rods. Good sharpness and tonal range. Tfs!
PaulVDV
(54853) 2018-02-03 2:25
Hello Gert,
Three very interesting and beautiful pictures taken along the Douro in Porto.
Despite the noise I really like your second workshop. It's excellently composed and combines different attractive elements. Not only the drying laundry but also the man sitting near the abyss and the people crossing the bridge.
An unusual comparison, at least for me, between these scenes and Italian movies from the 50's. But I know too little about films.
Best regards, Paul
Royaldevon
(75378) 2018-02-03 2:37
Hello gert,
I had to study my own thoughts to explain why I enjoyed these three shots so much!
Maybe it was just to see times when people were contented to share activities that were not expensive but fulfilling!
Although the three were about the bridge, it was the people that were most interesting.
The w/s, showing the solitary figure fishing, made me smile. I have never seen a fisherman looking so little like a fisherman! He appeared to be modelling his clothes in a playful way.
The second w/s was much more intriguing. It's very well composed, too. The f/g man is lost in his own thoughts but life is moving on without him as people stream across the bridge. It's a bit 'Brave New Worldish' !
Have a great w/e,
Bev :-)
kasianowak
(15818) 2018-02-03 2:43
Great series of three photos and you are right, they look so much like those Italian movies. Well-noticed!
The WS photo without the horizon is very atmospheric and I bet the man in the other one is not fishing for fun but his family is desperate for food.
Best wishes
Kasia
alvaraalto
(42276) 2018-02-03 3:02
Hello Gert
Black and white is here a splendid alternative for bad colours and if I may say so in this picture also for good colours. I like your association with the famous Italian cinema from this period. I only missed the names of Fellini and Antonioni 😉. I’ve seen a lot of their movie in that years.
Have a good weekend, groet Rob
BennyV
(32570) 2018-02-03 4:11
Lovely old picture, Gert. It looks a lot older than 1984. I visited Porto first in the early nineties, then later I was surprised how much had changed. This nostalgic shot reminds me a bit of my first visit there.
Benny
danos
(110407) 2018-02-03 4:40
Hell Gert,
Nice the B/W format with the lot of the young fishermen and the others to are so close to the sea.Excellent the snapshot as the light management.
Have a good WE,Danos
jmdias
(102900) 2018-02-03 4:59
gert
I liked the three images, maybe more of the other two ones.nice glimpse of the crowd in the edges of the river.the versions in B&W were correct I guess. this time was very difficult for portugal because many portuguese living in africa moved back to portugal and the country hadn't economic space for everybody, this was the case of two couples of my mother's family and their sons.
take care
jorge
Silvio1953
(205719) 2018-02-03 5:08
Ciao Gert, beautiful B&W, lovely composition with a lot of people, excellent perspective and splendid light, very well done, my friend, ciao Silvio
Lidka
(527) 2018-02-03 6:16
Dear Gert!
Ribeira in the city of Porto! Amazing place.
Fine black and white picture.
Superb point of view.
A lot of people.
Famous bridge in the background.
Good composition.
Original work.
Splendid effect.
Well done!
Sergiom
(117241) 2018-02-03 6:59
Bonjour Gert,
Une autre très belle pièce sortie de tes archives en noir et blanc et qui nous raconte une très beau moment de l'époque. Superbe point de vue et une belle histoire.
Amicalement
Serge
sacimar
(38173) 2018-02-03 7:34
Hello Gert,
this is another interesting image in your gallery, I like the scene with all of this people in the area around the famous bridge, the B&W is a perfect option here, well done!
Best regards,
Sergio
Tue
(82232) 2018-02-03 7:57
Hello Gert,
A great daily life photo from the banks of the river, which are crowded with many people. It does look like the still from an old movie indeed. Excellent composition, the city and the bridge further away make a great backdrop too.
Lars
Cricri
(176) 2018-02-03 10:19
Hi Gert
Je pensais que cette image était plus ancienne que la date noter, surement par le choix du N/B, les deux autre présentations sont aussi très intéressante , bien présenter et composer
Belle soirée
cricri
cornejo
(61504) 2018-02-03 11:38
Hello Gert, very good picture of this interesting scene of everyday life, excellent note. A great job perfectly done, my congratulations, my friend. Thanks for sharing this interesting work.
Good night and happy Sunday.
All the best from the south of Spain.
Angel.
GyurMaster
(21349) 2018-02-03 12:40
Dear Gert,
Converting to BW often helps, like asking who would like a tea, in an embarrassing situation. :)
Joking apart I haven't seen the original ones, but this is a really good shot. On the other hand the WS photos are even better, especially WS1. That is way more better and if you ever upload it, I will add it to my favourites.
Best Wishes,
Gy.
emka
(152194) 2018-02-03 12:54
Hello Gert, Who still remembers such names as Rosselini, Visconti or de Sica? I remember Bicycle thieves. On the other hand, I do not remember any Italian contemporary movies. Indeed it looks a bit like in these neorealistic films. From this set I like most the Workshop with the laundry above the river, and delicate view of the bridge with the silhouettes of the people on it. Black and white is a fantastic option in such cases. KInd regrads Malgo
carlo62
(81265) 2018-02-03 14:23
Ciao Gert
da italiano posso solo ringraziarti per aver ricordato i tempi d'oro del nostro cinema.
Sono d'accordo con Malgo, anche io preferisco la foto in verticale del ws, ma questo non toglie bellezza anche alle altre due foto.
Buona domenica
Carlo
tyro
(30513) 2018-02-03 14:31
Hello Gert,
As always, a fascinating note - and how resourceful of you not to give up on these particular scanned slides but to give them added life by converting all three images to black and white. In fact, if the quality of your "laundry" workshop slide was as bad as you mentioned to Bev, you have performed a remarkable feat of resurrection.
And, indeed, while all three photographs are very appealing, that one with the laundry out to dry is my favourite too: I simply love it. I mean there is the enormous bridge in the background which we see through mist or fog, the dozens of little figures and a few vehicles on top of the bridge, then there is the rather mundane foreground of washing hung out to dry and then - for some strange reason, we have a fellow apparently relaxing atop a precipice! I just wish I could print this one out and hang it on a wall here!
And all the more remarkable because you can't actually remember taking this one!
Absolutely Brilliant!
Kind Regards,
John.
Kind Regards,
John.
adores
(46979) 2018-02-03 15:02
Hi Gert!
Great series indeed! Now the city has changed a bit and there are lots of tourists around. These photos remind me of the old days.They are all very good daily scenes of that beautiful city.
Yes, that was a hard period. I still remember well the days of revolution and the years that came after.
rychem
(72179) 2018-02-03 15:50
The three historic photos in the black and white version look almost like daguerreotypes, a very good documentary series, greatly presented
regards Ryszard
papagolf21
(152599) 2018-02-03 22:08
Bonjour, cher Gert,
Merci de nous offrir cet album souvenir avec des images marquantes.
Le choix du noir et blanc est parfait pour rappeler le passé.
Je suis avec intérêt l'historique lié à cette composition.
Le résultat (rendu) est très bon.
Amitiés.
Philippe
macjake
(96157) 2018-02-03 22:57
Hi Gert
oh how times have changed right? I get the feeling Porto wasn't as touristy in 84 as it is now. Photographers and tourists have clearly 'found' porto, and now its a hoping mad tourist destination. If my memory is correct, this same viewpoint is now full of boats, tour boats, launching pads for tourists to line up to get on the boats...i think you get it!
great to see this shot when I was only 9 years old :)
cheers
Craig
jhm
(203003) 2018-02-04 5:22
Hello Gert,
More than thirty years ago it be real extraordinarily pictures.
Best that you have a very well archive.
Your create depth and perspective.
Sharpness and clarity be perfect
Composition and presentation are superb.
Very well done, TFS.
Best regards,
John.
lucasgalodoido
(26956) 2018-02-04 11:56
Olá Gert,
interessante essas fotos mesmo, e gostei bastante das imagens dos WS, principalmente a 1, merecia até um post só dela. A qualidade aqui, em P&B achei muiito boa. Belo trabalho.
Parabéns e Abraço,
Lucas
mcmtanyel
(58830) 2018-02-05 20:45
Hello Gert,
Sometimes B&W covers a multitude of sins, as is the case here. very nice view.
Regards,
MT
worldcitizen
(14272) 2018-02-07 12:58
Hello Gert,
The title of this photo pulled me in. My Master's Thesis, many years ago, actually included Italian neorealist cinema, and Vittorio De Sica in particular. There's an interesting array of people on the far, left side of the frame, and that works well with the large section showing only the river and the bridge. B/W was a good choice for this scene, too.
willperrett
(14029) 2018-02-08 4:20
Hello Gert
Fine old photograph! The comparison to Italian neo-realism is entirely justified: I now want to see "Roma città aperta" and "Ladri di biciclette" again! Similarly the decision to go monochrome is sensible, but then I would say that. I remembered to give your love to Kasia by the way. And she's sent me a copy of your novel, in translation and abridged, but I shall enjoy reading it...
Regards
Will
PiotrF
(52330) 2018-02-12 15:15
Hello Gert
An interesting composition along the waterfront in Porto.
Interesting note.
Pictures in the workshop are also interesting and together they are a great series.
Regards
Piotr
COSTANTINO
(104159) 2020-06-06 22:25
Hello dear Gert
you have a great treasure of worthseeing
photos perfectly executed from the past
giving to us so many impressive elements
about the life....
thanks for your useful notes in order
to understand better what this photo
presents...
regards
Costantino
Photo Information
-
Copyright: Gert Holmertz (holmertz)
(92852)
- Genre: ¢íèñùðïé
- Medium: Ìáýñï & Áóðñï
- Date Taken: 1984-08-00
- Categories: Êáèçìåñéíüôçôá, Áñ÷éôåêôïíéêÞ
- ¸êäïóç öùôïãñáößáò: Ðñùôüôõðç Ýêäïóç, Workshop
- Date Submitted: 2018-02-03 1:16
Discussions
- To Royaldevon: fisherman (1)
by holmertz, last updated 2018-02-03 02:58 - To alvaraalto: directors (1)
by holmertz, last updated 2018-02-03 03:20 - To willperrett: abridged (1)
by holmertz, last updated 2018-02-08 05:23