Photographer's Note
Second shot from Notre Dame. Prefer this with the slightly more graphical look to it.
Some people have mentioned the distortion (Phil & Ben), so this is what I think it was, no pp. The verticals were straight so no need for perspective control. This was straight out of camera. The distortion must be because of the change of axis to the film plane.
Some technical stuff:
Shift (rise and fall)
If you consider your camera pointing at a building, with the film/sensor plane perpendicular to the ground, the camera should be pointing to a point at the same height above the ground as it is positioned.
If you raise the lens, this aiming point moves away from the centre of the frame.
A simple example from landscape photography might help explain...
Lets say I want to take a scenic shot, with the horizon about one third of the way up the frame. If I just tilt the camera up to move the horizon down, it may not show much distortion. However if I've got tall trees or telegraph poles in the shot, they may start to lean at quite an angle. The solution is to shift the lens.
The sensor on my 1Ds is 36mm x 24mm. If I want to have the camera aim point moved down to 1/3 of the height of the frame I need a shift of 4mm (the centre line is 12mm from the bottom of the frame, I need it 8mm from the bottom 12- 8= 4mm) Similarly for portrait orientation I need 6mm of shift to get the horizon 1/3 of the way up the frame (18-12)
Any other suggestions welcomed ;D
Henryk_Bilor έχουν(ει) επιλέξει αυτή τη σημείωση ως χρήσιμη
Critiques | Translate
aadilj
(18102) 2008-03-10 1:33
Lovely and very well composed, i like the sue of perspective and depth and the management of lights and textures. good work indeed.
snunney
(130967) 2008-03-10 1:43
Hello Mark,
A very good composition with excellent perspective and depth. The exposure is well managed, not usually easy in these places. Very good tones and clarity.
devimeuxbe
(58557) 2008-03-10 1:46
Hi Mark
Beautifull cropping, beautifull exposure and composituin; You have captured a nice athmopshere in the cathedral.
Well done
Bertrand
Dyerco
(10185) 2008-03-10 5:51
An interesting perspective. There seems to be a slight tilt to the second arch at the top. Is that lens distortion or is it the building?
Phil
ben4321
(9875) 2008-03-10 6:20
Ah, I see you were using a TS lens for this Mark - you certainly did a good job in keeping the verticals vertical, although it looks to me like you used a bit of perspective correction in PP as well. The vaulted ceiling has a strange look to it, quite distorted.
I think your composition works very well though, and you managed the light nicely.
Cheers,
Ben
smarcell
(19965) 2008-03-10 6:37
Hello Mark, I like the way you have just barely included people in this picture. They give the right size of the building, and leave the rest of the picture for the church itself. Very nice
Stefano
michiels
(4170) 2008-03-10 13:44
hello Mark,
there is something strange, a kind of power taking you into the corridor to the end ... great perspective and nice dividing in the compo.
greetings, inn
PixelTerror
(0) 2008-03-13 1:24
Hi Mark,
Nice indoors view, due to the diagonal placements the arches perspective is a good leader to the main part. That's a rarely seen lens you have been using here, I was once considering to buy one because I often shoot buildings, but finally did not , are they really worth their price ?
Have a nice day JY
Henryk_Bilor
(20803) 2008-03-16 0:32
Hi Mark
Interesting capture with these distortions. Impressive interior and perspective. Good light too.
Have a nice day.
Photo Information
-
Copyright: Mark Nunnerley (marknunnerley)
(2780)
- Genre: Τοποθεσίες
- Medium: Έγχρωμο
- Date Taken: 2008-02-14
- Categories: Αρχιτεκτονική
- Camera: Canon EOS 1Ds, Canon TS-E 24mm F3.5L
- Έκδοση φωτογραφίας: Πρωτότυπη έκδοση
- Date Submitted: 2008-03-10 1:32
Discussions
- To ben4321: Distortion (1)
by marknunnerley, last updated 2008-03-10 06:46 - To Dyerco: tilt (1)
by marknunnerley, last updated 2008-03-10 06:49 - To PixelTerror: Yes & no (2)
by marknunnerley, last updated 2008-03-13 11:59