To mkamionka: Old photographs - The TrekEarth Forums


Go Back   The TrekEarth Forums >


Thread Tools Display Modes

Great mkamionka 2015-06-23 10:10

Hi Will,
Fiji seems to be so far away! I like very much the well saturated color tones especially the greenish sea and blue sky of course. Horse riders add a nice and relaxing touch here.
This is a very nice point to mark on a map I am genuinely jealous, you have already answered the question which straight away came to my mind: you have worked closer there and this is why it made sense to visit this place. Similar for me was the case when I lived in California I had a chance to go for short break on Hawaii, otherwise from Europe it does not make much sense...
Beautiful place -pity to hear that it is not as pristine as it was at the time of the picture taking.
Judging by the quality I would not guess this is such an old photo. All my predigital pictures are quite bad quality now. May be just because I never actually had a better camera before.


Old 06-24-2015, 08:30 AM
willperrett willperrett is offline
TE Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2011
Posts: 691
Default To mkamionka: Old photographs

Hello Mariusz

My experience is that negatives and transparencies are generally OK, so long as the lens of your (maybe cheap) camera was acceptable. The problem usually lies in how the originals are digitised. I seldom use prints: the original 1st generation negatives are always better: cleaner and sharper. Then the machine you use to do the digital conversion is important. A flatbed is never going to get such good results as a dedicated film scanner, though of course they're expensive. I used the one at the college I used to work at!

Here is a copy of an article I wrote on the Photography Forum a few months ago:

Scanning films
Over the months, I've posted many old film (transparency and print) originals, and often commentators have expressed surprise at the quality of these old images. Similarly I've seen others' scanned posts that really haven't done justice to what I imagine was the quality of the originals. So it seemed opportune to offer my thoughts/tips, as an ex-photography lecturer, on getting the best out of your old (and not so old) film photographs. Here we go:

a) good film originals (whether trannies or prints) were actually very good quality: I'm sure you remember the debate about film vs. digital, when for a long time it was acknowledged that film produced better ultimate quality than the then-available digital alternatives. Some pros still prefer film...
b) a high-end dedicated film scanner is needed. I have scanned literally hundreds of film originals on a flatbed, and then compared them to a couple of examples done on my college's film scanner: you didn't need a magnifying glass to see the difference. So I bit the bullet and scanned them all again, using a much better piece of kit.
c) I use a very high ppi: typically 4000, and at 16 bit depth, and with a detailed scanning algorithm that took a lot of pain to work out, including grain reduction, and so on. The files ended up 107 mg each, and so they remain, giving me 16 bit, 300dpi files of about 45 cm on the long dimension. I save them as TIFF files (i.e. no compression).
d) I try to do the minimum of editing to scanned files; but I always put them through what it pleases me to call my "workflow", involving Nik Dfine 2, further to suppress grain in plain areas of tone, like skies, and Nik Pro 3 RAW Presharpener, just subtly to tighten up edges. (I'd recommend the Nik range of plug-in filters, as I find them more discriminating than Photoshop's own Noise and Sharpen alternatives).

Sorry if this sounds like my being a lecturer again. I'm still convinced that film works, and scanned film can stand up to the best digital, if it's done right. I'd welcome anyone else's thoughts or comments on this matter.
Reply With Quote

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump

All times are GMT. The time now is 11:08 AM.

Copyright © 2018 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.